Debate Lessons

  • Essential Questions
    Content
    Skills
    Differentiated Instruction/Support
    Materials
     
    What is the Social Contract?
    How do Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau view the Social Contract differently?
    What is Maslow's hierarchy of ideas?
    What is Aristotle's vision of justice?
    What is John Rawls' theory of justice and his "veil of ignorance"?
    What is John Stuart Mills' "free marketplace of ideas?
    What is utilitarianism?
    What is Kant's categorical imperative?
    What is value debate? What is policy debate?
    What are equality, liberty/freedom, justice, human rights, individualism, community/responsibility, ethics, and relativism/sophistry?
    What is a resolution?
    What is the difference between a value and a value criterion?
    Why are definitions and observations important?
    How can this resolution best be defined and interpreted?
    What are the major affirmative and negative contentions/arguments in terms of the current resolution? What are the major rebuttals to those arguments? How can questions best be framed for cross-examination with respect to the current resolution?

    Debate concepts and techniques
    Philosophical concepts and techniques
    Current events
    Resolutional analysis
    Rebuttals
    Cross-examination
    Case-writing (essay writing)

    Resolutional analysis
    Development and refinement of rebuttals and cross-examination questions
    Case-writing (essay writing) and case (essay)revision
    Practice mock debates and note-taking ("flowing") of debate tournament rounds
    Research of current debate topics, extemporaneous speaking (current events) topics,
    and Model Congress bills and resolutions
    Discuss current events; practice delivery of extemporaneous speaking speech event
    Practice in and discussion of winning techniques for Extemporaneous Speaking, Model Congress, and Tournament Debate


    Case-writing (formal essay) for affirmative, development, and revision
    Case-writing (formal essay) for negative, development, and revision
    Development and refinement of cross-examination questions and rebuttals
    In-class mock debates, extemporaneous speaking speeches, and Model Congress practices
    Class participation

    class notes, internet and library research, current events periodicals

     
    How is a bill written for Model Congress?
    How is a resolution written for Model Congress?
    What is the format for Model Congress?
    How can this resolution best be defined and interpreted?
    What are the major affirmative and negative contentions/arguments in terms of the current resolution? What are the major rebuttals to those arguments? How can questions best be framed for cross-examination with respect to the current resolution?

    Debate concepts and techniques
    Philosophical concepts and techniques
    Current events
    Resolutional analysis
    Rebuttals
    Cross-examination
    Case-writing (essay writing)

    Resolutional analysis
    Development and refinement of rebuttals and cross-examination questions
    Case-writing (essay writing) and case (essay)revision
    Practice mock debates and note-taking ("flowing") of debate tournament rounds
    Research of current debate topics, extemporaneous speaking (current events) topics,
    and Model Congress bills and resolutions
    Discuss current events; practice delivery of extemporaneous speaking speech event
    Practice in and discussion of winning techniques for Extemporaneous Speaking, Model Congress, and Tournament Debate


    Writing a bill, a resolution, and an authorship speech (persuasive essay) for Model Congress
    Case-writing (formal essay) for affirmative, development, and revision
    Case-writing (formal essay) for negative, development, and revision
    Development and refinement of cross-examination questions and rebuttals
    In-class mock debates, extemporaneous speaking speeches, and Model Congress practices
    Class participation

    class notes, internet and library research, current events periodicals

     
    How can this resolution best be defined and interpreted?
    What are the major affirmative and negative contentions/arguments in terms of the current resolution? What are the major rebuttals to those arguments? How can questions best be framed for cross-examination with respect to the current resolution?

    Debate concepts and techniques
    Philosophical concepts and techniques
    Current events
    Resolutional analysis
    Rebuttals
    Cross-examination
    Case-writing (essay writing)

    Resolutional analysis
    Development and refinement of rebuttals and cross-examination questions
    Case-writing (essay writing) and case (essay)revision
    Practice mock debates and note-taking ("flowing") of debate tournament rounds
    Research of current debate topics, extemporaneous speaking (current events) topics,
    and Model Congress bills and resolutions
    Discuss current events; practice delivery of extemporaneous speaking speech event
    Practice in and discussion of winning techniques for Extemporaneous Speaking, Model Congress, and Tournament Debate


    Case-writing (formal essay) for affirmative, development, and revision
    Case-writing (formal essay) for negative, development, and revision
    Development and refinement of cross-examination questions and rebuttals
    In-class mock debates, extemporaneous speaking speeches, and Model Congress practices
    Class participation

    class notes, internet and library research, current events periodicals

     
    How can this resolution best be defined and interpreted?
    What are the major affirmative and negative contentions/arguments in terms of the current resolution? What are the major rebuttals to those arguments? How can questions best be framed for cross-examination with respect to the current resolution?

    Debate concepts and techniques
    Philosophical concepts and techniques
    Current events
    Resolutional analysis
    Rebuttals
    Cross-examination
    Case-writing (essay writing)

    Resolutional analysis
    Development and refinement of rebuttals and cross-examination questions
    Case-writing (essay writing) and case (essay)revision
    Practice mock debates and note-taking ("flowing") of debate tournament rounds
    Research of current debate topics, extemporaneous speaking (current events) topics,
    and Model Congress bills and resolutions
    Discuss current events; practice delivery of extemporaneous speaking speech event
    Practice in and discussion of winning techniques for Extemporaneous Speaking, Model Congress, and Tournament Debate


    Case-writing (formal essay) for affirmative, development, and revision
    Case-writing (formal essay) for negative, development, and revision
    Development and refinement of cross-examination questions and rebuttals
    In-class mock debates, extemporaneous speaking speeches, and Model Congress practices
    Class participation

    class notes, internet and library research, current events periodicals

     
    How can this resolution best be defined and interpreted?
    What are the major affirmative and negative contentions/arguments in terms of the current resolution? What are the major rebuttals to those arguments? How can questions best be framed for cross-examination with respect to the current resolution?

    Debate concepts and techniques
    Philosophical concepts and techniques
    Current events
    Resolutional analysis
    Rebuttals
    Cross-examination
    Case-writing (essay writing)

    Resolutional analysis
    Development and refinement of rebuttals and cross-examination questions
    Case-writing (essay writing) and case (essay)revision
    Practice mock debates and note-taking ("flowing") of debate tournament rounds
    Research of current debate topics, extemporaneous speaking (current events) topics,
    and Model Congress bills and resolutions
    Discuss current events; practice delivery of extemporaneous speaking speech event
    Practice in and discussion of winning techniques for Extemporaneous Speaking, Model Congress, and Tournament Debate


    Case-writing (formal essay) for affirmative, development, and revision
    Case-writing (formal essay) for negative, development, and revision
    Development and refinement of cross-examination questions and rebuttals
    In-class mock debates, extemporaneous speaking speeches, and Model Congress practices
    Class participation

    class notes, internet and library research, current events periodicals